CloudEnterprise.info

No real private clouds yet?

Posted by: Dmitry Sotnikov on: January 16, 2009

private-cloudHere I continue the 2009 predictions series started with my IaaS/PaaS 2009 post.

In the world of cloud computing we are living in very exciting times. Cloud Computing is the buzz word of the day even though the segment is barely two years old. Interest in private clouds is even more astonishing considering that these barely exist at all and we are likely to be only entering the first days of real developments in this area.

In a nutshell, private clouds are Amazon-like cost-effective and scalable infrastructures but run by companies themselves within their firewalls.

There are a couple of reasons why this is an interesting option for a lot of enterprises out there:

  1. Some data and systems belong on premise due to security and legal concerns, or simply companies wanting to stay in control.
  2. The story of not having to provision and manage hardware resources when using public clouds from Amazon and others sounds great but the reality is that enterprises already have hardware of their own. Instead of tearing down datacenters in which they have been investing all these years – why not start to use them more efficiently?

These are the reasons why both enterprise and government structures (you don’t expect Department of Defense to use Amazon for their apps, do you?) are very interested in pursuing the private cloud option, and analysts like Gartner are giving the concept their high blessing.

Surprisingly enough, I would argue that no real solution is currently obvious on the market.

VMware is working on their Datacenter OS and vCloud initiatives, and has had LabManager offering for a long time. Microsoft is obviously happy sell you their Hyper-V and Systems Center Virtual Machine Manager. And then there are quite a few startups like 3Tera (grid operating system), ParaScale (disk-storage aggregation software), Cassatt (resource-pooling technology), Elastra (cloud-like application management inside a company’s firewall) and so on.

However, I believe that the real solution is yet to come.

Here are the key characteristics that private clouds should have from my perspective:

  1. More than a hypervisor and VM management tool: storage services, standard scalability APIs such as load balancing and queuing, and so on.
  2. Unified approach with public clouds: APIs, software stack, licensing, virtual machine formats (in case of IaaS), development tools…

Unified public/private approach is important for a few reasons:

  • It would provide for scenarios like outbursting (using internal clouds most of the time and public ones for peak loads) and freedom to go to external vendors and back.
  • From development perspective, ability to write application once and sell it both as SaaS offering from a public cloud and software one for private deployments will stimulate software vendors to create solutions for the platform.
  • And obviously the more unified the technology gets the easier it would be for in-house developers and IT to have skills necessary to develop and manage applications of their own.

There are companies working on elements of private cloud systems of the future but there is nothing close to being a real solution with Amazon-like acceptance (still curious to see what happens to Eucalyptus in 09 by the way).

Will 2009 be the year when private clouds really take off? I seriously doubt so – there seems to be a lot of work ahead to make this a reality. However, there definitely is demand (for the reasons I mentioned above), analysts’ blessing, and a lot companies rushing in to deliver a solution. Which means that no matter how early things are we will see a lot of interest developments in this area in 2009.

Technorati Tags:
,

3 Responses to "No real private clouds yet?"

AT&T and the like can easily do fully private clouds on an NPLS network with total virtualized everything from server farms to firewalls.

Karl,

There’s definitely some terminology confusion here. What you are talking about is a datacenter vendor (in your case, AT&T), leasing to you a part of their datacenter and probably setting up VPN or something to make it appear as part of your network.

What I mean by private cloud is a completely different thing:

I am talking about companies wanting to use the hardware they have in their own datacenter and put some kind of “cloud OS” on top of that so their can have the flexibility and scalability that Amazon and other are getting but within their physical network under their control.

There’s a lot of the former – but not so much of the latter yet.

Dmitry

[...] in which he referenced and lauded Dimitry Sotnikov’s blog of the same titled “No Real Private Clouds Yet?“ I continue to scratch my head not because of David’s statements that he’s yet [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

RSS My company’s main blog

  • The Jelastic Spotlight May 25, 2012
    We are starting something new here on the blog for Fridays. Up until now, we were doing more light-hearted stuff but as we were sitting around talking about the different sweet apps that you, our customers, are deploying, we realized that we should be showcasing the apps and the developers! So, as of today, Fridays [...]
  • Remote Access to MySQL in Jelastic: Import/Export Dump Files in a Few Minutes May 24, 2012
    Recently, we told you about that another cool feature that you have access to in the commercial version of Jelastic, Public IPv4. With a single click you access to a number of cool new capabilities. One of the most important opportunity you get with this feature is the ability to work with your databases remotely and [...]
  • The Jelastic Newsletter – May 23, 2012 May 23, 2012
    Java 7 adoption, Commercial releases in Europe and Russia and Software stack market share. . . The Jelastic newsletter is a weekly round-up of news, how-to’s and contribution opportunities. Here’s what’s happening this week: Commercial Releases in Europe and Russia As we continue to grow and add partners, we are happy to say that, as of yes […]
  • We are now available commercially in Europe! May 22, 2012
    In partnership with dogado, we are now available commercially in Germany The last few weeks have been hectic here at Jelastic! We launched commercially in the US with ServInt; then we did the same in Russian with Rusonyx; and now we have launched commercially in Europe with Germany. Now in Europe Our commercial release with [...]
  • Software stacks market share: May 2012 May 21, 2012
    Every month we share stats on the usage and popularity of different software stacks within Jelastic PaaS with you. This month it’s even more interesting, because the scope of our stats has grown: we have a new hosting partner in Russia, Rusonyx. So, let’s check out the stats on databases, servers and JVMs for May and analyze the differences betwe […]
  • Geek Project of the Day May 18, 2012
    Just in time for the weekend. Here is your geek project of the day. Because sometimes, a regular grill is not enough. We want one. Going to “borrow” a friend’s car and turn it into a grill.
  • Jelastic announces the commercial availability of its Java cloud hosting platform with Rusonyx May 17, 2012
    Rusonyx’s Jelastic offering provides Cloud Java hosting with no lock-in or code changes required PALO ALTO, Ca. – Jelastic, the world’s first standards-based Platform-as-a-Service, today announced its commercial availability in Russia through its partner, Rusonyx, one of Russia’s leading web hosting service providers. Rusonyx is the exclusive provider […]

My Recent Tweets

Blogroll

Legal

The posts on this blog are provided “as is” with no warranties and confer no rights. The opinions expressed on this site are mine and mine alone, and do not necessarily represent those of my employer Jelastic or anyone else for that matter. All trademarks acknowledged.

© 2008-2012 Dmitry Sotnikov

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.